Is Kirkland dog food the same as Blue Buffalo

By Isabella Storyclaire

last updated November 18, 2024

Contributions sourced from

Kirkland Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo: Which One is Better?

Last updated on March 3rd, 2024 at 01:31 pm

Kirkland Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo are two of the most popular dog food brands on the market. As a dog owner, I recognize the significance of offering my four-legged companion top-notch nourishment that caters to their dietary requirements. However, with so many options available, it can be challenging to determine which brand is the best fit for my dog.

In this article, I will compare Kirkland and Blue Buffalo dog food to help you make an informed decision when choosing the right dog food for your furry friend. I will examine the ingredients, nutritional value, and pricing of each brand to determine which one is the better choice. By the end of this article, you will have a better understanding of the similarities and differences between Kirkland and Blue Buffalo dog food, allowing you to make an informed decision that meets your dogs nutritional needs.

Overview of Kirkland Dog Food vs Blue Buffalo

Selecting the right pet food for your furry companion can be a daunting task, given the plethora of options available for dog foods. Among the top brands that are often recommended for high-quality pet food recipes are Kirkland and Blue Buffalo. Having researched both brands, I can provide a brief comparison of the similarities and differences between the two, including their use of chicken meal in their ingredients.

Quality and Ingredients: Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo are known for producing high-quality pet food. Kirkland dog food is made with real meat as the primary protein source and contains no artificial colors or flavors. Blue Buffalo also uses real meat as the main protein source in their pet food and offers grain-free options for dogs with dietary restrictions. Both brands prioritize using quality ingredients and avoiding harmful additives.

Cost and Value: One of the main differences between Kirkland and Blue Buffalo is their cost. Kirkland dog food is more affordable than Blue Buffalo, making it a great option for pet owners on a budget. However, Blue Buffalo offers a wider variety of flavors and formulations, which may make it worth the extra cost for some pet owners.

Safety and Labeling: Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo prioritize product safety and ingredient quality. Kirkland dog food has had fewer recalls in the past than Blue Buffalo, which is a testament to their commitment to safety. Blue Buffalo also includes LifeSource Bits in their pet food, which are a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals designed to support your dogs overall health.

Nutritional Content: When it comes to nutritional content, both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer pet food with a balanced ratio of protein, fat, and fiber. Blue Buffalo contains controversial ingredients like peas and potatoes, which some pet owners may want to avoid. Kirkland dog food offers all-natural and organic options for pet owners looking for a more holistic approach to pet nutrition. Both brands include omega fatty acids in their pet food, which are important for maintaining healthy skin and coats.

Note: This post does contain affiliate links. If you purchase a product after clicking one of our links, we may earn a commission. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. There is no extra cost to you and I thank you in advance for your support!

Scroll the table to learn more

Title	Price	Buy
Kirkland Signature Dog Food Variety (Chicken, Rice and Vegetable Dog Food 40 lb.)	Buy Now	Prime
Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Dry Dog Food, Chicken and Brown Rice 15-lb	Buy Now	PrimeEligible
Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Puppy Formula Chicken & Pea Dog Food 20 lb	Buy Now	Prime
Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein Natural Adult Dry Dog Food Plus Wholesome Grains	Buy Now	PrimeEligible
Kirkland Signature Expect Moore Nature's Domain Salmon Meal & Sweet Potato Dog Food 35 lb.	Buy Now	Prime
Blue Buffalo Dog Food for Senior Dogs, Life Protection Formula	Buy Now	PrimeEligible

Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Pros and Cons of Kirkland Dog Food

I always want to make sure that my furry friend is getting the best nutrition possible. Kirkland appears to be a well-liked option for numerous pet owners when it comes to selecting a brand of dog food. Blue Buffalo is another brand that is often compared to Kirkland, but there are some differences between the two that are worth considering. Here are some of the pros and cons of Kirkland dog food based on my personal experience and research. Kirkland offers a variety of foods and recipes that provide a balanced meal for my dog. However, I always check the ingredients list as some suspect ingredients have been found in some of their products.

In my opinion, Kirkland dog food is a good choice for pet owners who want high-quality foods at an affordable price. Although there are some downsides, like limited availability and product variety, the brand uses quality ingredients in its foods and has received positive feedback from pet owners, making it a dependable option.

Pros

Affordable: One of the biggest advantages of Kirkland dog food is its affordability. As a Costco member, I can purchase Kirkland dog food at a lower price compared to other premium dog food brands.
High-quality Ingredients: Kirkland dog food uses high-quality ingredients such as real meat, vegetables, and fruits. The brand also avoids using artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors.
Variety of Formulas: Kirkland offers a variety of formulas for different life stages and dietary needs. They have formulas for puppies, adult dogs, and senior dogs. They also have grain-free and limited ingredient formulas for dogs with food sensitivities.
Positive Reviews: Many pet owners have reported that their dogs love the taste of Kirkland dog food and have seen improvements in their dogs health and energy levels.

Cons

Limited Product Line: Compared to other premium dog food brands, Kirkland has a limited product line. They do not offer as many flavors or formulas as other brands.
Recall History: Kirkland has had a few recalls in the past due to potential salmonella contamination. However, the brand has taken steps to improve its manufacturing processes to prevent future recalls.

Pros and Cons of Blue Buffalo Dog Food

After conducting extensive research and comparisons of different pet food brands, including Kirkland Signature, I have gained valuable insight into the advantages and disadvantages of Blue Buffalo dog food. This popular dog food has its benefits and drawbacks, and I am able to provide a brief overview of both.

Pros

Blue Buffalo offers a wide range of products, including dry and wet dog food, as well as treats and supplements. This makes it easy to find a product that fits your dogs dietary needs and preferences. Kirkland Signature or Kirkland brand options are not available in their product line.
Blue Buffalo, unlike Kirkland Signature, uses high-quality ingredients, such as real meat, vegetables, and fruits, and avoids using artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. This makes it a healthier option than some other pet foods that contain fillers and by-products.
Blue Buffalo offers a range of dry food product lines that cater to specific health needs, such as weight management, sensitive stomachs, and senior dogs. This allows you to choose a Kirkland Signature product that addresses your dogs specific health concerns.
Blue Buffalo has a strong reputation and is a well-known brand in the dog food industry. This can give pet owners peace of mind when choosing a product for their furry friend. If youre looking for an alternative, consider Kirkland Signature dog foods.

Cons

Blue Buffalo products can be more expensive than some other pet foods on the market, which may not be affordable for all pet owners. However, Kirkland Signature may offer a more budget-friendly option.
Some Blue Buffalo dry dog food products contain fish meal, which can be a controversial ingredient due to potential heavy metal contamination and sustainability concerns. Kirkland Signature also offers dry dog food options.
Blue Buffalo has faced several lawsuits and recalls in the past, specifically related to their dry dog food, which may cause some pet owners to question the safety and quality of their products. However, its important to note that other brands like Kirkland Signature have also faced similar issues.
Blue Buffalo is owned by General Mills, a large corporation that also owns other pet food brands, such as Purina Pro and Diamond Pet Foods. However, if you prefer to support independent and smaller pet food companies, you may want to consider the Kirkland signature brand.

In general, Blue Buffalo has advantages and disadvantages that pet owners should consider and determine if it suits their dogs needs.

Ingredients Comparison

Kirkland dog food is made with high-quality ingredients, including real meats like chicken, turkey, lamb, bison, trout, rabbit, and duck. These meats are excellent sources of protein, which is essential for building and maintaining strong muscles. In addition to meats, Kirkland dog food also contains sweet potatoes, which are a great source of fiber and essential vitamins.

On the other hand, Kirkland Signature, like Blue Buffalo, also uses high-quality meats like chicken, turkey, and lamb in their dog food. However, they do not use grains like wheat and soy in any of their formulas.

When it comes to amino acids, both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo contain the essential amino acids that dogs need to thrive. However, Kirkland dog food also contains chelated minerals, which are easier for dogs to absorb and utilize than standard minerals.

In terms of ingredients, I find Kirkland dog food to be a superior option compared to Blue Buffalo. Kirkland incorporates high-quality meats and other components that provide dogs with essential nutrients while avoiding grains that could be harmful.

Nutritional Value Comparison

Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer a range of dog food options with varying nutritional values. In this section, I will compare the nutritional value of Kirkland dog food and Blue Buffalo.

Protein

Protein is essential for building and maintaining muscle mass in dogs. Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer dog food options with high protein content. Kirkland dog food has an average protein content of 27-28%, while Blue Buffalo has 22-27%. This difference is relatively small, but its worth noting that Blue Buffalo has slightly more protein.

Fiber

Fiber is important for maintaining digestive health in dogs. Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer dog food options with a similar amount of crude fiber. For example, Blue Buffalo has 2.71% more protein, while Kirkland has 2.35% more. This means that both brands provide roughly the same amount of crude fiber in their dog food.

Fats

Fats are essential for the proper development and function of the canine body. Kirkland and Blue Buffalo both provide roughly the same amount of crude fat in their dog food. However, its worth noting that the source of fats can vary between brands. Kirkland dog food contains chicken fat, while Blue Buffalo uses fish oil and flaxseed as sources of omega fatty acids.

Omega Fatty Acids

Omega fatty acids are important for maintaining healthy skin and a shiny coat in dogs. Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer dog food options with omega fatty acids. However, the sources of omega fatty acids can vary between brands. Kirkland dog food contains chicken fat, while Blue Buffalo uses fish oil and flaxseed as sources of omega fatty acids.

Energy

Energy is important for maintaining an active and healthy lifestyle in dogs. Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer dog food options with a similar amount of calories per serving. However, its important to note that the calorie content can vary between different dog food options within each brand.

In conclusion, both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer dog food options with high nutritional value. While there are some differences in protein, fiber, fats, and omega fatty acids, both brands offer a range of options that can meet the nutritional needs of most dogs.

Quality and Safety Comparison

Both Kirkland Dog Food and Blue Buffalo are popular brands that offer a range of high-quality dog food options. However, there have been some concerns regarding the quality control and product safety of these brands.

Kirkland Dog Food has had some quality control issues in the past, which have resulted in a few recalls. However, the company has taken steps to improve its quality control processes and has not had any recent recalls. On the other hand, Blue Buffalo has had a few recalls in recent years due to potential salmonella contamination.

Kirkland and Blue Buffalo provide choices for dogs with particular dietary requirements, including sensitivities and allergies. Kirkland offers a grain-free line of dog food, while Blue Buffalo offers a range of limited-ingredient and grain-free options.

Both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo dog food brands claim to prioritize product safety by using high-quality ingredients and adhering to strict safety protocols. However, its important to understand that no dog food product can guarantee complete safety, and its advisable to observe your pet for any negative reactions.

Although both Kirkland Dog Food and Blue Buffalo are great choices for your pet, its crucial to conduct your own investigation and select the one that suits your furry friends specific requirements and sensitivities.

Price Comparison

Kirkland dog food is exclusively sold at Costco stores and is known for being an affordable option for pet owners. The price point for Kirkland dog food varies depending on the specific formula and bag size, but it is generally less expensive than Blue Buffalo.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo is a premium brand that is known for using high-quality ingredients in its dog food. As a result, their products tend to be more expensive than Kirkland dog food. However, Blue Buffalo often offers coupons and discounts for their products, which can help bring the cost down.

Its important to note that being a Costco member is a requirement to purchase Kirkland dog food, so if youre not a member, you wont be able to take advantage of their affordable prices. However, if you are a member, Kirkland dog food can be an excellent option for budget-conscious pet owners.

When comparing the price of Kirkland dog food and Blue Buffalo, its essential to consider the ingredients and nutritional value of each product. While Kirkland dog food is more affordable, it may not have the same quality of ingredients as Blue Buffalo. Its up to each pet owner to decide what is most important for their pets health and their budget.

To sum up, in terms of cost, Kirkland dog food is usually less expensive than Blue Buffalo. Nevertheless, its crucial to take into account the ingredients quality and nutritional value of both products before choosing one.

Taste and Variety Comparison

Kirkland dog food offers a wide range of flavors and recipes, including chicken, beef, lamb, and salmon. They also have grain-free options for dogs with dietary restrictions. I appreciate the variety of flavors available, as it allows me to switch up my dogs meals and prevent them from getting bored with their food.

Blue Buffalo also offers a variety of flavors, including chicken, beef, lamb, and fish. They also have grain-free options and recipes with Lifesource Bits, which are small, dark kibbles that contain a blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals. While I appreciate the added nutrition provided by the Lifesource Bits, some dogs may not enjoy the taste or texture of these kibbles. Additionally, if youre looking for an alternative brand, you may want to try Kirkland Signature.

In terms of taste, both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo receive positive reviews from pet owners. However, taste preferences can vary between individual dogs. Some dogs may prefer the taste of Kirkland, while others may prefer Blue Buffalo.

Kirkland and Blue Buffalo provide a decent selection of dog food flavors and recipes. Pet owners can select the most suitable option for their dog based on their dietary requirements and flavor preferences.

Which Brand is the Best Choice for Your Dog?

One of the main advantages of Kirkland dog food is its affordability. Kirkland offers premium dog food at a fraction of the cost of many other pet food brands. This makes it an ideal choice for pet owners who are on a tight budget. However, despite its low price, Kirkland dog food is still made with high-quality ingredients that are free from artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors.

On the other hand, Blue Buffalo dog food is a premium dog food brand that is known for its high-quality ingredients. Blue Buffalo uses only the best ingredients in its dog food, including real meat, vegetables, and fruits. This makes it an ideal choice for pet owners who are looking for high-quality dog food that is rich in nutrients. However, this premium dog food brand comes with a higher price tag than Kirkland.

In relation to dry dog food, Kirkland and Blue Buffalo provide a broad selection of options for grown-up dogs. Kirklands dry dog food is produced using authentic chicken, lamb, or beef, while Blue Buffalos dry dog food is created utilizing genuine meat, vegetables, and fruits. Both brands offer alternatives for wet dog food for dog owners who prefer it.

In terms of chew bones, both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer a variety of options for pets. Kirkland offers chew bones that are made with real meat, while Blue Buffalo offers chew bones that are made with natural ingredients.

Overall, both Kirkland and Blue Buffalo offer high-quality dog food that is rich in nutrients and free from harmful additives. The choice between these two brands ultimately comes down to personal preference and budget. Pet owners who are looking for an affordable dog food brand that still offers high-quality ingredients should consider Kirkland, while pet owners who are willing to spend more on premium dog food should consider Blue Buffalo.

Scroll the table to learn more

Title	Price	Buy
Kirkland Signature Dog Food Variety (Chicken, Rice and Vegetable Dog Food 40 lb.)	Buy Now	Prime
Blue Buffalo Life Protection Formula Natural Adult Dry Dog Food, Chicken and Brown Rice 15-lb	Buy Now	PrimeEligible
Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Puppy Formula Chicken & Pea Dog Food 20 lb	Buy Now	Prime
Blue Buffalo Wilderness High Protein Natural Adult Dry Dog Food Plus Wholesome Grains	Buy Now	PrimeEligible
Kirkland Signature Expect Moore Nature's Domain Salmon Meal & Sweet Potato Dog Food 35 lb.	Buy Now	Prime
Blue Buffalo Dog Food for Senior Dogs, Life Protection Formula	Buy Now	PrimeEligible

Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

Frequently Asked Questions FAQs

Which brand is better, Kirkland or Blue Buffalo?

It depends on your dogs needs and your budget. Both brands offer high-quality dog food with real meat as the first ingredient. However, Kirkland is generally more affordable than Blue Buffalo. On the other hand, Blue Buffalo has a wider variety of formulas to choose from, including grain-free and limited ingredient options. Ultimately, you should choose the brand that best meets your dogs nutritional needs and fits your budget.

Is Kirkland dog food made by Diamond Pet Foods?

Yes, Kirkland dog food is manufactured by Diamond Pet Foods, a reputable company known for producing quality pet food. Diamond Pet Foods also manufactures other popular dog food brands such as Taste of the Wild and Diamond Naturals.

Does Blue Buffalo use all-natural ingredients?

Yes, Blue Buffalo prides itself on using all-natural, high-quality ingredients in its dog food. The brand avoids using corn, wheat, soy, and artificial additives.

Does Kirkland dog food have any recalls?

Kirkland dog food has had a few recalls in the past, but they have been relatively minor and quickly resolved. In general, Kirkland has a clean recall history compared to many other dog food brands.

Is grain-free dog food better for my dog?

It depends on your dogs individual needs and preferences. While some dogs do well on grain-free diets, others may experience digestive issues or other health problems. Grain-free dog food is not necessarily better than dog food that contains grains. Its important to choose a dog food that meets your dogs nutritional needs and is appropriate for its age, size, and activity level.

Can I switch my dogs food from Kirkland to Blue Buffalo or vice versa?

Yes, you can switch your dogs food from one brand to the other, but its important to do so gradually over the course of several days to avoid digestive upset. Start by mixing a small amount of the new food with your dogs current food and gradually increase the amount over several days until your dog is eating only the new food.

Conclusion

After a comprehensive analysis of Kirkland dog food vs Blue Buffalo, I have concluded that pet owners and dog lovers should take into account certain factors before making a final choice.

Firstly, both brands offer high-quality dog food with natural ingredients and no artificial additives. However, Kirkland dog food is significantly more affordable than Blue Buffalo, making it a better option for pet owners on a budget.

Secondly, while Blue Buffalo offers a wider variety of flavors and formulas, Kirkland dog food still has a decent selection to choose from. Additionally, Kirkland dog food has consistently received positive reviews from customers, indicating that it is a reliable and trustworthy brand.

Thirdly, when it comes to the controversial topic of recalls, both brands have had their fair share. However, Kirkland dog food has had fewer recalls than Blue Buffalo, which may be a factor to consider for pet owners who are concerned about the safety of their dogs food.

In general, I believe that both Kirkland dog food vs Blue Buffalo is excellent options for pet owners who want to provide their dogs with high-quality, nutritious food. However, for those who are looking for a more affordable option, Kirkland dog food is the clear winner. Ultimately, the decision comes down to personal preference and what works best for your individual dog.

A Quick Comparison of Our Favorites